Michelle and Nayte celebrated with Season 18 third-place finisher, Joe Coleman.
The Bachelorette’s Michelle Young and Nayte Olukoya reunite with Joe Coleman on New Year’s
With Minnesota being their mutual home, Joe’s family joked during their hometown date that they hope it worked out between him and Michelle because they’d probably run into her at the grocery store.
They were on the right track.
Michelle found herself in the same place on New Year’s as her college basketball-playing ex.
Clearly showing no bad blood between the three, Michelle uploaded a photo onto her Instagram stories showcasing the all-smiles moment with her fiance and the bronze medalist of her season.