While at Casa Amor, Korey met two new girls that he connected with.
First was Isabel Johnson, who came on incredibly aggressive and seemed to leave Korey shellshocked, and possibly a little afraid.
The second was Leslie Golden, who Korey was instantly attracted to and with who he shared a middle-of-the-night breakfast.
In the end, Korey chose Leslie, and many Love Island USA fans felt it was a mistake.
The reason Korey chose Leslie
Korey had a tough choice.
First, Isabel was clearly high on him and wanted him more than any other girl in Casa Amor. However, she was very aggressive and demanding, and when Korey did his diary interviews, he seemed shook and didn’t really feel comfortable with that personality.
On the other hand, Leslie and Korey had what might be the most authentic conversation on Love Island USA this season when they had their cereal together in the middle of the night.
It was the first time it felt like two people really talking to each other without all the drama involved.
Korey clearly felt more comfortable with Leslie and that is why he chose her over Isabel.
However, there was one problem.
Isabel wanted Korey and only Korey. Maybe she just wanted to latch onto the best possible candidate and ride to the finish, but she only had eyes for him.
Now, Korey is at the villa and coupled up with a girl who has eyes for someone else.
Love Island USA viewers see this, but Korey followed his heart.
Twitter fans disappointed in Korey’s decision
Fans watching Love Island USA at home know that Leslie showed more interest in Cinco and felt Korey should have gone with Isabel, no matter how uncomfortable she made him.
“KOREY… -100 points for you. Isabel I’m so sorry baby,” @sharriyanicole wrote on Twitter.
“KOREY ISABEL WAS RIGHT THERE,” wrote @hoodmoanalisa.
“Still cant believe Korey didn’t choose Isabel like she was all for you while Leslie was all over Cinco. I just know Leslie still gonna be all over Cinco in the next episode,” @14xNonymous wrote.
Whether Korey can find love with Leslie, or if she has wandering eyes for other boys in the villa remains to be seen.
Love Island USA Season 3 airs on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Sundays at 9/8c on CBS.