Thomas Clayton is featured in an episode of Killing Time on Investigation Discovery for his murder-for-hire plot against his wife, Kelley Clayton.
On September 29, 2015, Thomas returned to his home on Ginnan Road in Caton, New York, and found his wife dead inside.
Kelley had been bludgeoned to death, and the only witness was their 7-year-old daughter, Charlie.
Instead of transporting Charlie to an intimidating interrogation room, police took her to the Steuben County child advocacy center for questioning.
Charlie told authorities that a man came into their home and began hitting her mother with a pipe-like object.
As her mother ran down the stairs, trying to get away from the person Charlie called a robber, she told her to run.
Charlie said the intruder beat Kelley until she was motionless on the floor.
At one point, Charlie told detectives that she hugged her mother’s leg as it looked as if she was suffering.
Investigators asked Charlie about the intruders’ appearance, and she said he looked like her dad.
Thomas immediately became a suspect in Kelley’s murder.
An investigation revealed that he hired his former employee, Beard, to kill his wife and set the house on fire so that he could collect insurance money.
However, Beard didn’t get around to setting the home on fire.
Beard told police that Thomas promised him $10,000 if he carried out the offense.
He later changed his story. Beard claimed that Thomas only hired him to burn his house down, not to kill anyone.
Despite his revised version of the story, Beard was charged and convicted of first-degree murder.
Thomas was also convicted of the same charge.
They were both sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Killing Time — Poker Faced Killer, airs at 10:00 p.m. on Investigation Discovery.
- Dennis Rader’s decades-long killing spree highlighted on ID special BTK: Chasing A Serial Killer - 28th August 2020
- Murder of Police Sgt. Roger Lamar Motley by Lynda Lyon Block and George Sibley detailed on Shattered - 23rd October 2019
- Murder of Danielle Marshall by Joshua Maurice Gibson featured on Truth About Murder with Sunny Hostin - 22nd October 2019