american idol fanApr 17th, 2008 - 03:40:20

...yes she is!... and it's about time!

Report this comment

MagsApr 17th, 2008 - 04:04:55

About damn time! That girl drove me mad!! Soooo annoying!

Report this comment

LaRueApr 17th, 2008 - 04:11:44

OMG! I am so glad she is gone. She should have been gone a long time ago.

Report this comment

Javan Stink BadgerApr 17th, 2008 - 04:23:12

But she was soo hot...doesn't that count for something?

Report this comment

AcyApr 17th, 2008 - 10:36:09

She was supposed to be in the beauty pageant...hehehe, she's so pretty, but she was supposed to leave American Idol long before M. Johns

Report this comment

RandomladyApr 17th, 2008 - 13:08:16

Kristy stepped it up the past two weeks and Brooke got worse. Based on the last couple weeks, I would have sent Brooke packing last night.

On a side note, Elliott Yamin was outstanding.

Report this comment

GinaApr 17th, 2008 - 13:30:27

I think Christy did get better as time went on, but Brooke is the most annoying one of the group and hopefully she'll be next. I don't think she can sing that well and her facial expressions and mouthiness are more than tiresome! I can't decide what type of song she is best suited for, and I wouldn't break my neck to ever buy her cd. Elliot looked great, and I would have liked to hear him sing a better song. Mariah's song was awful - good voice, terrible song!

Report this comment

donnaApr 17th, 2008 - 14:59:37

It was definitely Kristy's time to go. I wish everyone would get off of David A.'s case. He is a very good singer and should win it all. David C. is terrible and arrogant with his nose up in the air all of the time. Get rid of David C. next week!!!

Report this comment

Shar J.Apr 17th, 2008 - 15:51:17

David Cook could be the next Daughtry along with Michael. David A. has a tremendous voice and could go a long way given the right songs. I think it really puts a burden on the contestants to have to sing a particular celebrity's songs - they aren't always suited to everyone. They have to be songs that would sell, and there are a lot of cd's people wouldn't buy if there wasn't that one great song they like - sometimes the rest of the songs suck! I personally hated the one that Mariah sang last night, and that is supposed to be one from her new cd!

Report this comment

triceApr 18th, 2008 - 16:48:34

I like Brook's voice and the type of songs that she sings. I do not care for Syesha's song types and would not ever buy an album of hers. Carly is unappealing in every way and I would choose her to be the next to leave. I also like Jasons light and easy song style and would find an album by him fun and relaxing. The David's are good, just not my favorites.

Report this comment

KristyleeloverMay 31st, 2008 - 11:07:34

I liked Kristy! I didn't think she should have left then. I thought she was way better than Syesha.

Report this comment