Smallscreen

American Idol's Barba blows it?

Smallscreen News

By Stone Martindale Feb 24, 2007, 3:00 GMT


Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1  2 

bobbzFeb 24th, 2007 - 03:54:42

great, she's got my vote. i love freedom, thanks god this isn't iraq, iran, irun, or china

Report this comment

Kim KardashianFeb 24th, 2007 - 05:03:41

word, my brother....wahhhhhhhhhhhh wahhhhhhhhhhhhhhsob boohoooooooooooooo

Report this comment

Who cares?Feb 24th, 2007 - 05:44:08

Who cares what these girls did? And how dare anybody post any photos of them 'doing something.' Does Paris Hilton's 'career' end because she made a cheap, stupid porn film? Hardly. Does the media stop following Britney because she goes pantie-less one night? I think not.

Why do people care? Americans are so bizarre. We want our idols to be 'perfect' -- but they aren't. They are human beings. Does anybody remember Vanessa (L.) Williams? She was Miss America at one time, before Penthouse published nude photos she had posed for when she was 18.

So what? She was young, full of life, crazy, wild -- she did it. Perhaps she shouldn't have done it, but most young people are too stupid to think about the consequences.

Of course, nowadays, people are incredibly stupid if they think their 'activities' won't be seen by everyone in the world. On the other hand, it appears, sorry to say, that we're all pretty much stupid, everyone of us. We all want to have sex, we all want to think we're beautiful, sexy, hot, we all have problems, and we all need love and understanding (and stop the sniggering in the last row). Bottom line: Can these girls sing? That's what this contest is about, not whether or not they were dumb enough to pose nude in the Internet age. Why should these people be haunted by the sort of activity millions of other people engage in? That's because of the incredibly strange Puritanical mindset that Americans have and the 'image' they think certain people should have. Well, from Michael Jackson grabbing his crotch to Madonna performing fellatio on a bottle, to Christine Aguilera in her skimpy nothing being 'Dirty' to Robbie Williams baring his ass, to George Michael having sex in public with a truck driver ... you know what? Really, who cares?

Report this comment

aiskepticFeb 24th, 2007 - 06:29:27

Are we sure that's her? It doesn't like like her. She has a very prominent chin and nose...

Report this comment

NY ITCHFeb 24th, 2007 - 18:39:38

You know the other girl who came to audition with her? Well she's supposedly her 'best ' friend. And I think this 'best' friend is the culprit behind those online photos. Who else woudl have access to them? And also, if you have observed her behavior during the LA audition/competition towards Bailey Brown (another contestant) where she was cut, you know she is capable of doing this expose even at the stake of their supposedly 'friendship.'

Report this comment

courageFeb 25th, 2007 - 05:37:23

What is going to be amusing is when we find out who needle dick is. Let’s put a face and name to the little dick!

Report this comment

AreYouKidding????Feb 25th, 2007 - 16:08:12

This can't be for real, can it? So what! I thought American Idol was about talented singers. I think she's getting booted because once everybody gets access to these pictures she'll start getting more votes!

Report this comment

jade274Feb 25th, 2007 - 23:44:35

As much as I luv the poor little gurl she looks so innocent and sweet but I do think she be best to leave the show to save her dignity if that was me an in the same predicament I would of gapped it ages ago and made some excuses in y i was leaving who knows they could be fake pic's but anyways I don't think she's that greater singer and she will go maybe in the next show I will be shocked if she's still there after that I be even shocked if she carries on and win the Idol.

Report this comment

chachachaFeb 26th, 2007 - 01:05:57

she can't sing anyway so she's got to focus her energy SOMEWHERE

Report this comment

I totaly agreeFeb 26th, 2007 - 13:34:50

I totaly agree with the 'Who cares' comment...

Report this comment

DeeFeb 26th, 2007 - 15:51:21

Yayyyy, I'm glad that there's one less bad singer gone. I knew she would keep coming back like a bad penny because votefortheworst.com was going to keep that girl in it. Now she can stop acting like she's better than the people in her neighborhood. I hear that she's been pretty mean to the people since she made the top 24.

Report this comment

What?Feb 26th, 2007 - 18:21:36

Tell me who here hasn't given a BJ or been on the pleasurable receiving end?

I thought so hypocrites!

Report this comment

What?Feb 26th, 2007 - 18:21:47

Tell me who here hasn't given a BJ or been on the pleasurable receiving end?

I thought so hypocrites!

Report this comment

HypocritesFeb 26th, 2007 - 18:24:12

How about Randy?

How about Simon? I bet his girl tastes his popsicle every now and then!

You telling me Paula Abdul never given a BJ to make it this far in the entertainment industry?

We all know Seacrest loves to blow!

Report this comment

SammyFeb 26th, 2007 - 22:18:00

Calling her a bimbo is a little much. You guys are full of...you know what.

Report this comment

ftwilliamsFeb 27th, 2007 - 02:04:26

American Idol is a waste of a show and a time slot.The comment about'Americans are Bizarre' I will not respond to because it sounds like the comment of a misinformed foreigner.Who cares if the girl has some indecent pics,it's obviously a disgruntled friend or ex or maybe even a p.r. tactic.Seems like being a ex-drug abusing,ex-nude or inappropriate behaving young lady these days will get your spread in a girly mag.

Report this comment

PointyHeadFeb 27th, 2007 - 03:21:54

So she DOES know how to use her mouth!

Report this comment

bradFeb 27th, 2007 - 19:30:51

American Whore rules.

Report this comment

sincitypervertFeb 28th, 2007 - 06:29:48

She should be ashamed of herself, not from giving head, but for not posting vids of it. If I really cared about the show enough to vote, I'd vote that she starts doing porn. Specifically the Gag Factor series from JM Productions. I mean really, she already lost her dignity, she's probably losing a potential big payday from American Idol, and she'll probably take up a killer meth habit soon, if she doesn't have one already. A perfect candidate for porn, and a perfect candidate for me to wack off to. She should just try skipping the act of trying to save face and don't even bother like she still has any dignity, the only thing it looks like she has is a smokin slutty little body, and a talent for sucking penis. I also wouldn't mind seeing her in American Gokkun #4, or even on firsttimeswallows.com

Report this comment

OilmanMar 3rd, 2007 - 00:22:02

The sad thing is that she cannot sing anywhere near as well as the other female contestants and I beleive that she is only staying in in the competition due to her ability to use her throat in a far different way than for producing music.
As a result there are some really talented singers being sent home and the depth of the competition is suffering.
I think the producers need to step in and send her packing in the same way that they did with that girl in Season 2 before the whole thing becomes even more laughable than it already is.

Report this comment

page: 1  2 

Latest Headlines in Smallscreen

Bookmark and Share Share

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Taylor Swift Mocks Kate Gosselin, Kanye and Joe Jonas on 'SNL'
Susan Boyle Coming to 'Dancing With The Stars'
Ten Celebrities Who Need To Join Twitter
Lamar Wants Khloe Kardashian Pregnant
PopEater Poll Results: How You Voted on Rihanna, Mariah, Anderson and Taylor

Latest Cinema Blend News

Script Reaction: Duncan Jones And Jake Gyllenhaal's Source Code
Lawrence and Foxx Resurrect Sheneneh And Wanda
The Slammin' Salmon Trailer: Broken Lizard Serves Up Funny
Moon Director Brings Jake Gyllenhaal Source Code
Weekend Box Office - Christmas Comes Early... Again

Latest Tech Herald News

Shamed Brit cop busted for stealing videogames
RTFM: Jailbroken iPhones get iRickrolled due to weak SSH access
Review: Motorola Droid
Facebook settlement means little in the long run
Naked Windows 7 vulnerable to Malware if left in default state
USA