Science News
Astronomers divided over 'planet' definition
Aug 22, 2006, 16:55 GMT
On the Web
Latest Headlines in Science
- 1. CleanSpace One Satellite Images
- 2. Swiss plan to send waste-disposal satellite into space
- 3. EU provides funding for 'affectionate' robots
- 4. Tiger poachers growing bolder, experts say
- 5. Europe vows to maintain Mars missions, despite NASA's absence
Older Talkback
page: 1
I can't believe the pettiness of some of these scientists/astronomers. I am an amateur astronomer and this embarasses me. Blaming MS because the spell checker didn't define plutons? I just can't believe it. Very disappointing.
The spellchecker comment was a joke... 'quip'
We are in big trouble. Scientists who need spell checkers, please. I have a better idea. Let the public vote the planets either in or out like they do on American Idol.
Then there is the naming of these so called planets. Xena? Pluto? Again, they could have a contest to name whatever new planets are voted in. Why imagine the publicity for all of this. Now the person who submits the winning entry would ride in a space shuttle for two weeks. Real exciting.
One question. If they decide the change the roster of planets would this mean I would have to throw out all these books on astrology I paid good money for.
Re: Planet Definitions
Why not define planet as one with gravitational impact?
Or, Pluto was found because in explained motion of other planets.
The newer 'planets' probably have zilch impact since it took so
long to discover them.
And as they must have some force, limit them by setting a threshold.
Or too minor in force to consider....
And call them 'Plantlets'?
Pluto has NO effect on anything but it's moons. Astronomers looked for a planet beyond Neptune to explain irregularities in Uranus and Neptunes motions, and after a century found Pluto. By accident it turned out. All 'irregularities' in Uranus and Neptunes orbits have been explained by other means, and Pluto is far, far too small to have any effect whatsoever on Neptune, let alone Uranus. So there.
page: 1
Your Talkback on this Story