People

Jessica Lynch debunks 'hero' myth, stands with Tillman's family

People News

By Stone Martindale Apr 24, 2007, 17:29 GMT


Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8 

trampledApr 24th, 2007 - 18:00:24

The US government is now worse than the soviets were. The propaganda isn't even well thought out. It'sxd obvious that they don't know the truth anymore, since they've spun so many lies they can't even keep them straight in their own minds anymore.

Lie to cover up a lie...

Report this comment

PatriotApr 24th, 2007 - 18:02:28

what a sin this war has been, we won't 'win' anything but a guaranteed future of even more enraged muslim hordes looking to kill us. We need smarts in our leadership to battle their irrational faith. Interesting that Sheryl Crowe, despite her wacky suggestions-is dead on in promoting biofuels. If we did not need to import oil we could tell the middle east to beat it What a great day that would be! I think green awareness and fuel alternatives are as American in spirit as the tea party in Boston all those years ago.

Report this comment

BackboneApr 24th, 2007 - 18:19:07

As americans we are all such cowards and simpletons. We can't figure out that we need to flood Iraq with soldiers and overcome this challenge.

Are we all so scared and weak-minded that we run when we see adversity. It is appalling and disappointing, it seems like this country needs another Pearl Harbor or 9-11 before we will have resolve hardened.

Iraq was a mistake we all know that now, but how we handle our mistakes is what will define us as a country. I wish we had a politician who wasn't afraid to say this is how we will win the war in Iraq. Instead we are all pining away for a spineless leader who wants to cut and run. Focus on welfare, abortion and any other liberal pet issue.

Our country has steadily declined in our economic prowess and inventiveness since we lost Vietnam. I wonder how low we will sink after we lose Iraq because of all the spineless folks.

Report this comment

tbApr 24th, 2007 - 18:23:22

If we stopped buying middleast fuel their countries would become even poorer and their suppresive leaders would still blame the US.causing more Jihadist Islam is evil, pure and simple truth. It has give these repressed people someone to blame instead of their evil and unhuman religion that keeps them unstified with their human existance!

Report this comment

ChristinaApr 24th, 2007 - 18:26:02

Leaving this war is not about being spineless. It's about realize we made a mistake and righting out wrongs. Are the Iraqi people honestly better off now than before? Are they actually 'free'?? They still live in fear of their lives and under the influence of a negative controlling force. If anyone is spineless, it is our leader for not being man enough to admit his mistake and his lies and right this wrong. Soldiers are dying every day for a war that the American public does not support and for a war that was started under false pretenses. How many years has it been since that banner read 'Mission Accomplished' and don't try to spin any bull about him not knowing about that. He's the president, I don't believe for a second he doesn't know what a sign behind him says.

Bottom line, we must find a way to get out of Iraq. Not only for our own good, but for the good of the Iraqi people. We have become enablers and are probably causing more violence in the country by our mere presence.

Report this comment

kevin cormierApr 24th, 2007 - 18:26:06

i was at fort bliss with ms. lynch she was a slut and as for tillman do you honestly think special forces shot thier own? the truth is is that in the army there is a saying that there is no such thing as friendly fire. my bet is that tillman showed his buddies he couldnt be trusted so they took actions. thats the truth of war if you have quarrels then join the army or work in politics and change it dont just sit around typing complaints on the internet. my bet is you are all stupid, media brainwashed minimum wage liberals.

Report this comment

JeanieApr 24th, 2007 - 18:26:12

I think it is time for the American people to stand up and say enough to Bush and Cheney and their illegal war. What has Bush done that was not a lie in the years that he has been in office.. I honestly believe that he is a disgrace to the office and I wish Congress had the nerve to stand behind the American people and do what they voted them in for.

Report this comment

MachiavelliApr 24th, 2007 - 18:26:14

Patriot, why do you call the Muslims faith irrational? Is it more so than Christian faith? The attitude that Islam is 'irrational' is one of the things that makes this war worse than it has to be: The Muslim community in the Middle East know that many 'Westerners' think Islam 'irrational' and many believe that the U.S. is fighting a war on Islam, not terrorism. To be fair I don't think that extremists should take it as far as they have (bombings etc.), but it is not as if they haven't been provoked. This war has made a mess that we will not be able to fix for decades, maybe longer, but the least we can do is not call shots against a faith that is given an extreme bad rap by its radicals and extremists that claim that is is the will of Allah/God.

Report this comment

tbApr 24th, 2007 - 18:26:21

If we stopped buying middle-east fuel their countries would become even poorer and their suppresive leaders would still blame the US, causing more Jihadist. Islam is evil, pure and simple truth. It has give these repressed sheeple someone to blame instead of their evil and unhuman religion that keeps them unsatisfied with their human existance!

Report this comment

Beltway GregApr 24th, 2007 - 18:27:20

File this under Bush's 'Mission Accomplished' Cheney's 'The insurgency is in its final throes' Condi's 'Why We Know Iraq Is Lying' Rumsfeld's 'We know Where the weapons of mass destruction are' Wolfowitz's 'The war will pay for itself.' Almost makes you want to pull your kids out of college and send them to work digging ditches. How could this seemingly well educated lot make so many mistakes and mistatements? Are we the people really this stupid or are Americans as a group delusional and easily led?

'Fate's Right Hand, I don't understand at all.' Rodney Crowell

Beltway Greg

Report this comment

John LarsonApr 24th, 2007 - 18:27:33

Since this is all about the truth then lets look at the big picture. I am a little supprised by the media intensity of Pat Tillmans death. The facts as reported by other soldiers there are now available for everone to view. No this is about a failure to present the truth in a timely maner. Since that is also obvious then Everyday Americans fight and die for a war

Report this comment

rskaeterApr 24th, 2007 - 18:28:02

it's just more of the same. LIES LIES LIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!this admin. has lied about everything since they were put in office by the (oil) powers that be. That was the start of the lies. That mr. bush 'won' the election. the Iraq war.. wmd's...etc. etc. etc. to have the Military LIE to promote his war is absolutely outrageous.. Why in the world isn't this admin. IMPEACHED? Anyone who believes ANY of these people...has to be living in the same sh t pile these people crawled out from.

Report this comment

DanApr 24th, 2007 - 18:29:53

Lynch was the young veteran who was savaged by Iraqi soldiers and who nearly lost her life in service to her country.
Give me a break! She got caught under fire, was treated and essentially released before her fellow officers 'came to her rescue'.

Report this comment

icantsleepApr 24th, 2007 - 18:31:51

I recall seeing Jessica on the motivational speakers circuit in Charlotte, NC shortly after she returned home. She didn't seem to mind all the hoopla about her story then.......my have times changed.

Report this comment

PuzzledApr 24th, 2007 - 18:31:55

Backbone,
Where will the troops to 'flood Iraq' come from? Are you advocating reinstatement of the draft?

Report this comment

The OmsbudsmanApr 24th, 2007 - 18:31:59

Fact check, please:

1) The claim that Lynch was sexually assaulted came from Rick Bragg, who wrote a book about her. Lynch herself has never claimed she was sexually assaulted, nor that she was mistreated.


2) The American doctor who examined Lynch said she received excellent medical care, especially in light of the conditions in Iraq at the time. This medical care included using one of the last bone braces in Iraq to stabilize her injuries.

Report this comment

LAZApr 24th, 2007 - 18:33:10

Let's talk about saving lives and even enhancing those of people with real illnesses that can be helped. BE FOR MORE STEM CELL RESEARCH.

Let's talk about saving lives... by coming home from Iraq and then taking care of our returning vets, and especially those that are injured. Enough is enough.

Let's talk about saving lives... by helping those in need here, at home. People who are in need of medical insurance, from children to seniors.

You are not a coward or anti-patriot when you express your unwillingness to swallow the lies and distortions of this administration. Beef up our own borders. We cannot win a war that has been fought for most of recorded history... by fuedal tribes and religions. Zealots who cherish not peace but martyrdom.

Report this comment

PLOPApr 24th, 2007 - 18:33:18

the war was completely legal, unfortunately. signed and sealed with permission of the UN and congress of the US to use force. John Kerry, Hillary, and Edwards all agree with bush.

Report this comment

TOM FLORESApr 24th, 2007 - 18:35:13

Kevin cormier, will you accept a collect call?

Report this comment

KirbyApr 24th, 2007 - 18:36:22

You got that right 'trampled'. Our government, press and corporate organization have trampled on individaul rights in this country long enough.

Report this comment

page: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8 

Latest Headlines in People

Bookmark and Share Share

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Khloe Kardashian Relives Wedding Day
Joel Madden Walks Out of Interview in Oz
Inside Jessica Lowndes' Moulin Rouge-Themed 21st Birthday Party
The Evolution of Britney and Her Men
Kevin McHale Leaves the Wheelchair on Set, Spills Juicy 'Glee'-tails

Latest Cinema Blend News

Biel Talks A-Team, Original Cast Making Cameos?
Oscar Eye: Predicting The Winners Following Precious's Giant Success
Kenny Chesney Rides A 3D Houseboat Into Theaters
Danny Elfman Out As Wolfman Composer
Is Rachel McAdams A Spider-Man 4 Villain?

Latest Tech Herald News

Modern Warfare to sell 5 million copies in 24 hours
Google pumps its mobile muscle with AdMob acquisition
Media-servers.net hit in massive code injection spree
Facebook stays tough on shady advertising
The Tech Herald’s daily usage journal for the HTC Eris
USA