Supreme Court to hear Navy's appeal in sonar case

US News

Jun 23, 2008, 19:37 GMT

Washington - The US Supreme Court said Monday it will hear the Navy's appeal of a ruling that restricts the use of sonar off the California coast to protect marine life. A federal judge on February 4 ruled against the Navy, rejecting President George W Bush's waiver that granted the service an exemption from environmental regulations limiting the use of sonar during training missions. The federal court in Los Angeles ruled the Navy must follow rules that restrict the use of the powerful radar designed to find and track submarines, and enforce a buffer zone within 20 kilometres of the California shore. The active sonar must also be shut down if marine mammals are spotted within 2,000 metres of the ships, under the current rules. The Navy and environmental groups have been sparring for years over the health effects of the sonar on sea life. The Navy says it already takes steps to minimize the impact on whales, dolphins and other mammals and that the training is vital to national security. Environmentalists argue the effects of sonar can harms the creatures and can cause whales to beach themselves. The Natural Resources Defence Council brought the legal challenge on behalf of a handful of other environmental groups. 'It's clear both that high intensity military sonar can injure and kill whales, dolphins, and other marine life and that the Navy can reduce the risk of this harm by commonsense safeguards without compromising our military readiness,' Joel Reynolds, director of the marine protection at the NRDC said Monday. The NRDC is ready to argue before the Supreme Court, Reynolds said. The high court will hear the case this fall. The Navy welcomed the decision, while noting that it has instituted 29 measures to protect sea life, including lookout stations, passive acoustic monitoring for marine mammals and setting up safety zones to reduce the sonar power or shut it down if marine life is spotted. The Navy said it strives to find a balance between the need for an effective combat force and protecting the environment, and that the measures backed by NRDC harm force readiness. 'These restrictions make it very difficult to conduct the kind of realistic, integrated training exercises that ensure the combat effectiveness of our force,' said Vice Admiral Samuel J Locklear, commander of the US Third Fleet in San Diego, California.

Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1

The Navy needsJun 23rd, 2008 - 21:22:17

to use the sonar in order to learn how to differentiate between Good whales and those Al Qaeda trained suicide mammals. The thought of an explosive belt attached to a whale has them blubbering. I bet the Department of Homeland Insecurity and Paranoia had a hand in this.

Report this comment

inappropriateJun 23rd, 2008 - 21:38:08

‘The Case against Barack Obama,’ we believe the media has whitewashed the candidate.”

Barack has been White-Washed........imagine that!!!

Report this comment

SP4: Gee, that's great but...Jun 23rd, 2008 - 22:34:27

Barack Obama has nothing to do with this article.

Report this comment

Defend Dolphins and PeoplesJun 24th, 2008 - 08:20:25

Besides the dogs (friendly ones) the dolphins are our best friends, shoot, they even love to save our lives. Therefore, it is worth every dolphin life we save or do no harm to; yet, the navy needs to find a way to protect us and still have a viable option for defending our coasts.

Get to work on it and quit whining to the Supreme Court.

Report this comment

Barack Who?Jun 24th, 2008 - 08:22:43

SP4 or 1/4, whatever...

You be humorous at times. Keep it up...

Report this comment

SP4: yeah, sureJun 25th, 2008 - 14:08:52

excuse me, I have to go eat a Dolphin.

Report this comment

BenJun 26th, 2008 - 15:59:37

And that would be a Mahimahi - perfectly acceptable to eat!

Report this comment

page: 1

US

Supreme Court to hear Navy's appeal in sonar case

US News

Your Talkback on this Story

Talkback

Similar articles

Latest Headlines in US

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Latest Cinema Blend News

Latest Tech Herald News

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print