US

US Intel says Iran has no nukes

US News

By M&C US News Dec 3, 2007, 20:13 GMT


Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1 

GrerryDec 4th, 2007 - 02:00:30

Cheney looks as if he was just fed a crap sandwich. It looks good on him. More of his lies exposed.

Report this comment

PperfectDec 4th, 2007 - 02:04:48

They are just working the spin on this new information. This administration does not need anything as trivial as 'facts'. Getting close to a year to be rid of these complete and total failures.

Report this comment

SP4: Let's see...Dec 4th, 2007 - 02:13:46

..Iran has over 100 nuclear research facilities


Iran allegedly has over 3000(?) enrichment centrifuges....(they only produce bomb material)

Iran has no real nuclear electrical power program to speak of


No wonder Cheney isn't smiling...

Other fabulous US intel coups:

Bombing of Chinese Embassy in Romania due to complete lack of intel

US missile gap of the 60's

Pearl Harbor

Bay of Pigs

Aldrich Ames

Oh yeah, they don't want a bomb....







Report this comment

File ItDec 4th, 2007 - 02:28:51

Under the dumbest thing I have ever heard.

Report this comment

Wrong again, sp1/4Dec 4th, 2007 - 03:01:06

'Iran allegedly has over 3000(?) enrichment centrifuges....(they only produce bomb material)'

Iran has plans for 3000. they currently have only 2 operating centifuges. They are of very poor design and low quality. They probably don't even work. Centrifuges are used to enrich uranium so that it can be used as fuel in a reactor. Due to heavy metal contamnination, the uranium Iran possesses cannot be enriched beyond 20% without further special prosessing in Russia China, or the US. Far, far below the 98% needed. As a matter of fact Iran will have a very difficult time getting it to the 3% needed for use as reactor fuel.
If you want to stop nuclear proliferation, take away the 200 nukes that Israel has built with US technology, guidance and raw materials. So, Mr. know-it-all, chew on that for a while. Stop spreading the Bush/Cheney lies.

Report this comment

Still wrong ,,, @wrong again ... RogérDec 4th, 2007 - 11:47:28

For clarification, I recommend Wikipedia on ''nuclear enrichment''.

Fact is, that enrichment for fuel rods in reactors requires U235 at an enrichment level of 3.5 to 5%, for which a cascade (installed in a series) of 3,000 centrifuges is needed. A gas, uranium hexaflouride, is routed to this cascade, enriching the remainder at each step more, using centrifugal (center-fleeing) forces -- the principle of a centrifuge, duh!

To make weapons grade uranium, the compound needs to be enriched to roughly 95% U235, but for this enrichment, cascades of 30,000 centrifuges are needed. This early November 2007, IAEA's ElBaradei noted, that Iran had had enormous difficulties in getting the 3,000 centrifuges to work in a cascade, but they succeeded and indeed produced a small amount of 3.5% fuel-rod material.

Bear in mind here, that Iran's first nuclear reactor is still not operational, and has not yet been equipped with nuclear 'fuel' by Russia. The uranium used by Iran is domestically mined, and the Iranians plan to eventually use their own uranium for fuel in their nuclear plant(s), after the initial set of fuel rods supplied by Russia.

Here comes the kicker!
The article states:
'We judge with high confidence that in fall 2003, Tehran halted its nuclear weapons program,' the report says. ... end of quote ...

In 2003, Tehran may have been in experimental stages on how to enrich uranium from uranium hexaflouride, made from domestic yellow cake -- but Iran's program certainly could not be called a ''weapons program'' back then, when they barely managed, four years later, to produce a small amount of fuel grade uranium as opposed to weapons grade uranium, that requires a ten- to twenty times larger infrastructure.

The US-backslapping on how well diplomacy and ''pressure'' works, is ludicrous. Iran did suspend its enrichment activities (largely experiments) in 2003, because it was promised by the EU3 (France, Germany and the UK) that it would receive technical assistance, a promise that was wiped off the table by Cheney/Bush and cohorts.

Given, what the IAEA knows about Iran's uranium enrichment program, anyone outside the CIA can also ''judge with high confidence'' that Iran does not have a weapons program. To even hint at such a program having been given up in 2003 is already bullshitting the public, but the administration should be allowed to try to save face, made necessary, because the IAEA did not cave in this time round. In 2003, the IAEA did find traces (for SP4: ''minute parts'') of highly enriched uranium, but it was meanwhile determined that these traces stem from contamination of the Pakistani centrifuges, where they were used in that nation's weapons program.

One last thing, reserved for ''SP4:'':

''Bombing of Chinese Embassy in Romania due to complete lack of intel''

During the Kosovo conflict, the Chinese Embassy in Belgrade was bombed by NATO (intentional or not will be eventually found out). Be advised, that Belgrade is the capital of Serbia (back then: Yugoslavia).

Report this comment

PperfectDec 4th, 2007 - 13:58:31

Typical information from SP4---'Fox News', 'Rush News'. SP4 gives us information just like this administration gives us information---90% lies- 10% truth.

Report this comment

page: 1 

Latest Headlines in US

Bookmark and Share Share

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Khloe Kardashian Relives Her Wedding Day
Joel Madden Walks Out of Interview in Oz
Inside Jessica Lowndes' Moulin Rouge-Themed 21st Birthday Party
The Evolution of Britney and Her Men
Kevin McHale Leaves the Wheelchair on Set, Spills Juicy 'Glee'-tails

Latest Cinema Blend News

Oscar Eye: Predicting The Winners Following Precious's Giant Success
Kenny Chesney Rides A 3D Houseboat Into Theaters
Danny Elfman Out As Wolfman Composer
Is Rachel McAdams A Spider-Man 4 Villain?
Goran Visnjic Is One Of Mike Mills' Beginners

Latest Tech Herald News

Modern Warfare to sell 5 million copies in 24 hours
Google pumps its mobile muscle with AdMob acquisition
Media-servers.net hit in massive code injection spree
Facebook stays tough on shady advertising
The Tech Herald’s daily usage journal for the HTC Eris
USA