US House apologizes for slavery, reviving reparations call

US Features

Jul 31, 2008, 3:16 GMT

Washington - The apology by the US House of Representatives for slavery has renewed discussion in the United States about reparations for descendants of African-Americans who were enslaved for more than two centuries in the early years of the country. But the decibel level was remarkably low on the topic after the US House on Tuesday adopted a resolution apologizing to black Americans for the 'fundamental injustice, cruelty, brutality and inhumanity of slavery' and the subsequent segregation that kept them out of schools, jobs and neighbourhoods. News coverage of the non-binding resolution - passed by a simple voice vote - slipped to page three in the Washington Post and barely merited note in the country's other major newspapers. The vote came months after the US Senate apologized for atrocities against native Americans, and two decades after Congress apologized to Japanese Americans for internment in World War II concentration camps - and paid 1.25 billion dollars to 60,000 camp survivors and their descendants. In 1988, the US government paid eight Sioux Indian tribes 122 million dollars for tribal lands illegally seized in 1877. To some critics, like Roger Clegg, president of the Centre for Equal Opportunity, a conservative think tank, the apology represented political grandstanding by the chief sponsor of the vote, Representative Steve Cohen, who is Jewish. While Cohen rallied co-sponsorship from 42 members of the Congressional Black Caucus, according to the Post, none of them have endorsed Cohen in his bid for renomination by Democratic voters in his home district in Memphis, Tennessee. Cohen's chief challenger in the August 7 intra-party primary election is a black lawyer, Nikki Tinker. Nonetheless, reparation advocates viewed Tuesday's vote as a 'very important first step' toward reparations. 'The bill does acknowledge the history of slavery and Jim Crow legislation and how it continues to impact African-American lives today,' said Kibibi Tyehimba, co-chair of the National Coalition of Blacks for Reparations in America (NCOBRA) in Washington, in a telephone interview. The group is part of an international reparations movement founded in 2002 in Bridgetown, Barbados, a year after after participants in a United Nations conference on slavery in Durban, South Africa, sidestepped the issue of payments and even failed to agree on the need for an apology for past exploitation. John Conyers, a left-wing black congressman from Michigan, is the hero of the US reparations movement for his annual attempt to earmark 8 million dollars to establish a commission to determine if slavery has a remaining impact on African-Americans - such as disproportionate imprisonment and higher death rates from disease. His resolution has never received support from Congressional leaders, even in his own party, but Tyehimba said that Tuesday's apology 'opens the door for continued discussions' of Conyer's bill. The NCOBRA leader noted that not only Japanese-Americans but also Jewish Holocaust survivors have received the benefit of US tax money. She said that Holocaust victims living in the US were exempted by Congress from paying taxes on reparations from the German and Austrian governments since the late 1990s. Clegg told Deutsche Presse-Agentur dpa that the slavery apology as well as possible reparations do 'not heal wounds' but keep 'wounds open.' 'It's backward looking rather than forward looking,' he said. Noting the diverse makeup of the US population, he said, 'It doesn't make sense for part of us to be apologizing to another part of us. The slave owners are all dead. The slaves are all dead.' Clegg believes the hurdles facing African-Americans today cannot be blamed on slavery but rather on elements such as the fact that 'seven of 10 are born out of wedlock. That's a figure that is much worse now than it was 40 years ago.'

Talkback

Add your comment (no registration required)

page: 1 2 3 4 5 6

slavery ended 143 years ago.Jul 31st, 2008 - 05:47:09

Close to 360,000 almost entirely white union soldiers killed and 275,200 maimed to end slavery doesn't mean squat in the culture of perpetual victimization.

Report this comment

Congress needs to be beaten like a pinataJul 31st, 2008 - 05:53:45

'John Conyers, a left-wing black congressman from Michigan, is the hero of the US reparations movement for his annual attempt to earmark 8 million dollars to establish a commission to determine if slavery has a remaining impact on African-Americans'

8 million bucks.... sigh.

Good thing they are addressing this instead of $4.20/gallon gasoline.

Or the wars. Or the national debt. Or the borders, or health care for veterans, or the erosion of our manufacturing base, or... etc, etc...

Report this comment

@8 million bucks.... sighJul 31st, 2008 - 11:54:12

Compare it to the costs of the war in Iraq,about ten minutes of warfare

Report this comment

lanceJul 31st, 2008 - 14:43:42

The world will have to wait 150 years before congress apologizes for mass killing muslims and striking out against an arbitrary country and taking them over.

It seems that the United States likes what they do ... until 150 years later when they change their mind.

Genocide and slavery. The United States gets away with murder (literally!).

Report this comment

SP4: Aren't all the slaves...Jul 31st, 2008 - 17:16:10

...dead?

Report this comment

MargeJul 31st, 2008 - 17:17:31

Good timing for Barak.

Report this comment

lanceJul 31st, 2008 - 17:30:03

'SP4: Aren't all the slaves ...dead?'

Indeed. All genocidal maniacs make the same argument.

By that argument the following is true:

If all christians are killed, converted or expired through attrition then they are all dead. Then would one need to apologize for the deed? Make restorations to the (presumably) left over pagan children (if any of their parents were christian)?

How convenient, just wait for all victims to die, then everything is all right; as long as the genocide is 100% complete.

Report this comment

Iraq is just another excuse.Jul 31st, 2008 - 18:44:00

'Compare it to the costs of the war in Iraq,about ten minutes of warfare'

Or welfare, prisons, unwanted children born to single mothers, the 'great society' programs etc.

People are personally responsible for their own destiny. The sooner we all realize that the sooner we will see equity.

Report this comment

to the resident islamist on M&CJul 31st, 2008 - 18:48:18

lance
'The world will have to wait 150 years before congress apologizes for mass killing muslims and striking out against an arbitrary country and taking them over.'

I am not at all sorry for getting rid of Saddam. Indeed, most of the muslims that you want the USA to apologize for were slaughtered by other muslims... You know, the ones you come here to make excuses for.

'If all christians are killed, converted or expired through attrition then they are all dead.'

Which is exactly what the Koran tells muslims to do to Christians and every other non islamic religion.

You should pack up, go to the middle east and preach your BS there. I wonder how long it will be until we see your empty head chopped off on the internet?

Report this comment

lanceJul 31st, 2008 - 19:12:36

'I am not at all sorry for getting rid of Saddam'

Sure, anyone who mass kills should be brought to justice, including Bush. So what? That is obvious.

However, using Saddam as an excuse for mass killing muslims and invading and occupying a nation is just about as bogus as the excuses:

(a) Weapons Of Mass Destruction

(b) 9/11

or any other lame excuse you can generate.

Report this comment

page: 1 2 3 4 5 6

Add your comment (no registration required)

US

US House apologizes for slavery, reviving reparations call

US Features

Talkback

Similar articles

Latest Headlines in US

Latest Articles on The Tech Herald

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print