Female circumcision, a centuries-old custom defying religion

Middle East Features

Jul 8, 2008, 11:08 GMT

Cairo - Twenty-two years ago, Fatma, a 34-year-old domestic servant living in Cairo, had her clitoris cut out according to a centuries-old custom. Seven years ago, she had the same operation performed on her daughter, Shaima, who was then 12. Now she is outraged to learn that the Egyptian government has banned the practice - and wonders how she will be able to have the same operation performed on her eight-year-old daughter Basma. 'How can they stop something that our ancestors have been practising for ages? Our mothers and grandmothers earned their respect and preserved their honour by undergoing tahara!' Fatma exclaimed. The word 'tahara' literally means 'cleanliness,' but is used to refer to circumcision in colloquial Egyptian. And without the operation, Fatma fears that she may not find a man willing to marry Basma. 'This is our tradition and the custom of our village. Every girl has to have it,' she says, echoing the view of millions of Egyptians who have their daughters undergo the clitoris-removing surgery, usually between the ages of 7 and 12. A survey conducted by Egypt's Ministry of Health as recently as 2005 found that 96 per cent of all women interviewed have had the procedure. They all believe that the removal of the clitoris helps prevent promiscuous behaviour in girls. 'The government is not abiding by the tenets of Islam,' Fatma concludes. Like millions of Egyptians, she is repeating without question the traditionalists' argument which ascribes to religious belief cultural traditions that are tolerated, but not mandated, by the Muslim faith. Among the traditionalists was Sheikh Gad al-Haq, Egypt's grand Sheikh of al-Azhar, the country's highest religious authority, in the 1980s. He endorsed female circumcision, thus undermining a government campaign to ban it. The custom of female circumcision predates Islam, but it was not eradicated by the early Muslims because they followed the fundamental tenet that what is not prohibited is allowed. Though female circumcision is not prescribed by the Koran, one saying ascribed to the Prophet Mohammed allows it. Many clerics say, however, that this saying is not authentic. Moreover, opponents of circumcision argue that in the very birthplace of Mohammed, the present-day ultra-conservative Saudi Arabia, the practice is regarded as a pre-Islamic abomination. In other countries adopting a strict version of the Islamic Sharia law, such as Afghanistan under the Taleban and Iran, female circumcision is virtually unknown. But many of Egypt's Coptic Christians, who are as conservative and guided by traditions as their fellow Egyptian Muslims, practice female circumcision although it is not prescribed by their faith. In recent years, the campaign against female genital mutilation has gathered strength in Egypt with the rise of an alliance between official political forces, non-governmental activists and official religious leaders, culminating in its criminalization. In 2006, the current grand Sheikh of al-Azhar, the moderate Islamic scholar, Mohamed Sayyid Tantawi, spoke out against genital cutting at a conference on the subject. 'From a religious point of view, I don't find anything that says that circumcision is a must [for women],' Tantawi said, contradicting a ruling by his predecessor, Sheikh Gad al-Haq. Another top Egyptian official Islamic scholar, Sheikh Ali Goma, told the conference no examples of the practice could be found in the life of the prophet Mohammed. The scholars maintained that Islam forbids people to inflict harm on others and argued that this is exactly what those who circumcise their daughters are doing. 'The real challenge is to convince the thousands of non-official yet influential imams and preachers, who have a sway over people in villages and towns and are opposed to the ban on circumcision,' says Gihan Mostapha, a social worker involved in the campaign against female circumcision. To a sceptical public, like Fatma, campaigners will have to repeat the official religious discourse that the practice is not Islamic. 'In Egypt's patriarchal society, the challenge is to re-educate men that they cannot adopt parts of religion that suit them and serve their interests and ignore the parts that are favourable to women,' Mostapha says.

View blog reactions

If you liked this story please support M&C and Buzz the site on Yahoo.

Latest Headlines in Middle East

Talkback

Add your comment (no registration required)

page: 1 2

juhaJul 9th, 2008 - 04:37:21

well if they want as an adult to mutilate themselves...let em. but dont make someone who is not an adult, cause you cant turn back. Unless the Law allso allows the children to sue their parents for performing the mutilation when they turn into an adult. this way they cant hide behind their belief as an excuse to perform the act of mutilation.

Report this comment

SP4: a pityJul 9th, 2008 - 21:45:53

..that they do not remove male muslim's heads. (either one)

Report this comment

It is purely US method of suing ..Jul 9th, 2008 - 23:37:17

Suing some one does not protect anyone. Preventing an injury is the only way to prevent injury.

NOW FEMALE CIRCUMCISION IS TRAUMA TO HUMAN BEINGS AND NO RELIGEON ALLOWS IT. aCTUALLY IT IS PUNISHIBLE UNDER ISLAMIC LAW. ALL ONE NEEDS IS ISLAMIC LEADERS IN THOSE SO CALLED MUSLIM COUNTRIES.

It is a shame that nobody enforces, from Church to so called Muslim governments.

Report this comment

????Jul 10th, 2008 - 17:27:54

It seems a shame to remove something that could give them pleasure. Oh I forgot muslim women are not supposed to do that.

Report this comment

IT IS YOUR DOUBLE FACED HYPOCRICYJul 11th, 2008 - 09:53:59

Muslim women are human beings and not as your holy book says. Even your god did not know that woman is essential second half of man, and not just a comforter, as Adam was not happy with other things, your god thought could take place of woman. READ;
www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Genesis%201:1-21;&version=31;31;49 ;45;

SIT BACK AND CRY PVER WHOM YOUR WORSHIP!!

Report this comment

Seriously...Jul 12th, 2008 - 02:25:02

'THOSE SO CALLED MUSLIM COUNTRIES' are begging on their hands and knees, dreaming, fantasizing, and PRAYING for some of you to come in and tell them what´s what about Islam.

Report this comment

GooseJul 17th, 2008 - 08:09:19

IT IS YOUR DOUBLE FACED HYPOCRICY...dude your an a hole, are you serious with this female mutilation shit? That about as pure as evil as I have ever seen.

Report this comment

Non- believer.Jul 22nd, 2008 - 16:49:38

There will never be sanity in the World as long as we have religion in it.

Report this comment

WomenStandUpAndBeCounted!Aug 1st, 2008 - 14:48:10

Any man who performs this surgery should have his weiner cut off.

Report this comment

CharlesAug 1st, 2008 - 16:05:52

It sounds more like 'clitoral amputation' - rather than circumcision.

Report this comment

page: 1 2

Add your comment (no registration required)