Iran's transsexuals: religiously acknowledged, but rejected

Middle East Features

By Farshid Motahari Jan 21, 2007, 4:42 GMT

Tehran - Transsexuals have a tough life in Iran. Although they are acknowledged in religious terms, there is very little tolerance shown towards them by society, not even by their own families. The young Iranian woman filmmaker Sharareh Attari made the highly controversial issue the main theme of her new documentary, It Sometimes Happens, which deals with the life of the young man Amir who undergoes the process of turning into a woman, Rima. Even during his childhood Amir felt that he was not like other boys. In his teenage years, the religious Amir wrestled with his conscience as he thought he was gay due to his sexual preference for boys. Eventually, however, he realized that physically and psychologically he was a woman and decided to undergo surgery to become Rima. As soon as Rima went public with her decision, her father abandoned her. Even her mother stopped seeing her regularly and eventually abandoned her as well. Her sister, although tolerating her decision, preferred to avoid her so that she would not get into trouble with her husband. Although Rima finally realized her dream of becoming a woman, her humble wish to have a husband and children and lead a normal life did not come true. Twice she fell in love, but both relationships came to an abrupt and bitter end after she told the two partners about her background. At the end of the 42-minute film, we see her sitting in a cafe crying because she doesn't have a partner or children in her new life. 'I wanted to show that transsexuality is no sexual perversion but an anatomic necessity,' Attari said after a private showing of her film in Tehran. However, the message of the film could not be conveyed to the public as despite receiving the permission of the highly conservative ministry of Islamic culture and guidance to make the film, a public screening has so far been prevented. 'Society is very prejudiced and is not ready yet for such a film. This would be too much provocation,' a ministry employee said. Filmmaker Attari has fought hard for a public screening, but she has faced hurdles from various sides. 'But I keep trying as these people are part of our society and deserve to get public attention and lead better lives,' she said. Despite societal prejudice, religious leaders in Iran have a rather liberal approach towards transsexuals. The late leader of the Islamic revolution, Grand Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, issued a decree almost two decades ago declaring that being a transsexual was permissible for those who are at odds with their gender. After her surgery, the religious Rima even visited an Islamic scholar in the city of Qom, which is considered to be the centre for Shiite clerics in Iran, to make sure that she had not interfered with God's will. The cleric gave her his blessing and said that the clergy followed the decree of the late Ayatollah Khomeini in this regard and she should not be afraid of having manipulated God's will and not going to heaven. Since then Rima prays, like all other Muslim women, wearing a chador, a long gown Islamic women wear to cover their bodily contours and hair. Most transsexuals believe that a life in the West would be much easier for them due to the open-mindedness in Western societies. 'Once I was crying loudly in my bed and my father came, watched me crying and just ignored me and left,' said Shida, another transsexual. 'After all, regardless of whether I am a boy or girl, I am his kid, he made me, but ignoring his own flesh and blood shows that if you cannot get the understanding of your parents how can you expect any from strangers,' Shida said. There are no precise statistics as to the number of transsexuals in Iran as many of them do not dare to go public with their problem. 'Just changing gender cannot be the ultimate aim because as long as you are not accepted by your own family - let alone society - how can you expect even a minimum of happiness,' said a woman who is currently going through the same process as Rima. 'I feel that God does not love us and sometimes I feel that a UFO has come and taken all the strange creatures to another planet but left us behind,' she added. © 2007 dpa - Deutsche Presse-Agentur

Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1

SP4: Take a Number...Jan 21st, 2007 - 23:19:21

...so do jews, catholics, sunnis's kurds, hindu's...the irish, dogs, cats...

The only thing missing is the Swastika.

Sig Heil!

Report this comment

Michael ReineltJan 22nd, 2007 - 10:26:34

It is remarkable, how suddenly the news about horrible things in Iran receives prominence ... before the assault-style mugging the Pentagon and Cheney/Bush have in store for the country.

But they are sinking fairly low, below the beltline, literally, when they're misusing such unfortunates in their scheming. Iran is obviously not an ideal society, but name one that is.

SP4 advances ignorance to a new level -- if Iran could be viewed in many ways (certainly not a wholesome society by Western standards, but U.S.-ally Saudi-Arabia is far, far, far more reprehensive a culture), ... fascistic, expansionist, imperial Iran is not, rather the opposite: it strives to discourage any outside interference, ...
... because ...
... the fascistic, expansionist, imperial U.S. is consistently doing just that, all the U.S. is truly lacking is a swastika on their tanks and warplanes. If one looks closely, the steel helmets of todays U.S. mercenaries resemble those of the old German Wehrmacht. The imperial arrogance is also the same, but the lack of efficiency is noticeable ... clearly, there are still only Americans in those uniforms ... actually the dregs of American society, one hears.

'Sieg Heil Fuehrer Bush, wir dummen Amerikaner folgen Dir wohin Du willst!'

Report this comment

page: 1

Middle East

Iran's transsexuals: religiously acknowledged, but rejected

Middle East Features

Your Talkback on this Story

Talkback

Similar articles

Latest Headlines in Middle East

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Latest Cinema Blend News

Latest Tech Herald News

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print