Is selective reporting responsible for videogame vilification?

PS3 Features

By Stevie Smith Dec 22, 2007, 7:38 GMT

Journalists bashing videogames and gaming for the sake of sensationalist press is becoming a worrying trend that must be thrilling the world’s anti-videogame activists as they look to tie gaming to the behaviour of dangerously imbalanced sociopaths. Videogames in the firing line as journalists ignore the truth in favour of a good story. Credit: Leggnet.com

Videogames in the firing line as journalists ignore the truth in favour of a good story. Credit: Leggnet.comFor example, this week saw two violent videogame incidents reported by the mainstream media in the United States. In both cases, the ensuing reports focus in on videogame hardware and software being the main contributing factors that ultimately led to outbursts of violence by those involved.One such report claims that Antonio Castillo (37) stabbed his nephew, Luis Alberto Santana (34), in the head and abdomen this past Thursday "following a fight over a PlayStation," in Chattanooga, Tennessee. However, the same report then outlines that Castillo had left clothing, a TV, and a PlayStation at his nephew’s house and an argument broke out when he returned to collect them. It is therefore little more than witch-hunt journalism to isolate the PlayStation as the sole catalyst for the attack. The media dare not blame the attack on TV, one of its biggest audience platforms, but what of videogames? Now that’s a massively popular rival medium they can help knock down a peg or two with some choice reporting and a spurious tone of condemnation.Furthermore, other reports have this week rolled the sensationalist ‘let’s bash videogames’ bandwagon in the direction of Frankie Starling, who suffered a gunshot wound to the leg courtesy of Geoffrey Alford (25), after an argument broke out while the latter was playing videogames with Mr. Starling’s cousin. Was the argument about the sometimes-controversial content of videogames, their potentially negative effects on society, or whether the Xbox 360 is better than the PlayStation 3? No, according to local authorities, the argument erupted because one of the three parties would not close a door. But do the press choose to highlight this seemingly banal but vitally important aspect of the incident? No, of course they don’t, because that just won’t shift print in a time when blaming videogames for all of society’s evils is the fashionable thing to do. Instead they choose to conveniently pick up on the fact that the shooter had come over to play videogames – thereby guaranteeing a readership for that particular story.Truly horrific attacks do transpire that potentially place videogames in a poor light; the recent death of a 7-year-old girl in Colorado who died at the hands of two teenagers allegedly re-enacting "wrestling moves" from Mortal Kombat is one such foul incident. However, that doesn’t necessarily mean that random acts of domestic violence, from which a journalist can connect an excruciatingly tenuous link back to videogames, should see gaming unfairly and unjustly vilified because the watching world needs something to fear.In the case of the recent spate of gun shootings across the US, perhaps an outdated yet all-but untouchable Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights (drafted between 1789-1791), which allows virtually any imbecile barely out of puberty to own a firearm, should be the first port of call for the patriotic knee-jerk reactionaries who immediately look to whether the shooter played videogames by way of a trusty scapegoat.In criticising America’s undying love affair with the right to bear arms, the late, great (American) comedian Bill Hicks said it best when he said: "There’s no link between having a gun and shooting someone with it, and not having a gun and not shooting someone. And you’d be a fool and a Communist to make one."

View blog reactions

If you liked this story please support M&C and Buzz the site on Yahoo.

Latest Headlines in PS3

Talkback

Add your comment (no registration required)

page: 1

BatzarroDec 23rd, 2007 - 01:27:07

I think Zoe Trujillo's death is highly suspect. Beating up someone 'accidentally' is a hard claim to hold. You can't just break someone's wrist and watch them writhe if your not a saddist. Furthermore, Mortal Kombat's moves are not generally wrestling type techniques. I wasn't there to see if they were doing roundhouses, uppecuts or flying bycicle kicks, but I get the distinct feeling they wern't pretending, just beating her up. I call bull on the 'enacting moves part'.

Report this comment

Shizno32Jan 4th, 2008 - 03:04:08

Agreed, and also notice that almost every single 'video game related' shooting happens in the United States, which also happens to be the only country where both firearms and video games are freely and cheaply available.
I live in New Zealand (you know, that tiny one on the bottom of the planet), where you have to pay annual fees just to have a firearms license, let alone a gun (though the games are still freely, but not as cheaply available). And we have never had a single documented occurence of any kind of 'video game related' shooting.

Report this comment

ZephyrJan 15th, 2008 - 04:35:43

On the same note, my sister was telling me about a radio.. broadcast I guess. It was saying something to the effect of that for every two hours you spend playing video games, your hcance of contracting Diabetes grows by 'x' amount percentage.
Yes, this is a proven fact, however, it isn't just video games! The REAL study is that for every two hourse of being sednitary! (not moving, sitting). That means the percentage growth occures every time you watch a movie, watch t.v. attend a concert, a wedding, dirve in the car, go on a plane... SLeeping!!!!!!!! Browsing the net.. anything when you aren't moving!
But on the radio 'report:' they only say,.... 'For every two hours you spend playig VIDEO GAMES!'!!!! To me.. people that cut down 'VGS' are new age hippies just looking for something to hate. Also.... people that are usually involved in a 'game related violence' are most of the time phsyco anyways! games didnt do a thing but maybe hold OFF their outburst by having them take out their anger on the game... it gave their 'victim' time if anything

----Zephyr

Report this comment

page: 1

Add your comment (no registration required)

Latest from M&C Blogs

Debate: did McCain do enough? - Global Eye on September 29, 2008 6:46 AM | Permalink | Comments (19) | TrackBacks (1)

Should Sen. John McCain's health records be made public? - Global Eye on September 15, 2008 8:39 AM | Permalink | Comments (49) | TrackBacks (0)

Propaganda and the campaign for president - Global Eye on September 9, 2008 7:12 AM | Permalink | Comments (10) | TrackBacks (0)

London Film Festival - Dean Spanley - London Calling on October 6, 2008 9:38 AM | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)

Raindance Film Festival: Gardens Of The Night - London Calling on October 6, 2008 9:21 AM | Permalink | Comments (1) | TrackBacks (0)

London Film Festival - IL DIVO Review - London Calling on October 1, 2008 3:46 PM | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)

Bugatti Veyron 16.4 Grand Sport - The World in Pictures on October 2, 2008 4:15 PM | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)

Devotee to Chinese Shrine of Sapam has face pierced - The World in Pictures on October 2, 2008 4:13 PM | Permalink | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)

Indian Muslims offer prayers on the occasion of Eid-al-Fitr - The World in Pictures on October 2, 2008 4:11 PM | Permalink | Comments (1) | TrackBacks (0)

PS3

Is selective reporting responsible for videogame vilification?

PS3 Features

Latest Headlines in PS3

Talkback

Latest from M&C Blogs

Similar articles

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print