DVD Review: C.S.I Season 4.2

DVD Reviews

By Andy McKeague Jul 12, 2005, 22:10 GMT

There is not much of a point to go into plots and characters, the good guys win and the characters are given no depth whatsoever, actually the only way you can tell the difference by what season you are watching is by how much plastic surgery Marg Helgenberger (Catherine Willows) has had done. With each season there are a few possible nip and tucks and the skin gets that shiny look; well at least someone is making use of the profits of its success !

Ok dear reader, this is the point where I say I had to do this so all of you don’t need to, I had to watch it to write this, but then again on hindsight, I could have written this after only watching the very first episode because they are all the same. Like a cross between ‘Quincy’ and ‘Playschool’ we are treated to a crime and then are amazed by how the Crime Scene Investigators gather their evidence, then we are shown their train of thoughts of how the crime may or may not have been committed and then there is always that one vital clue that they turn to the screen and grin that sums up how they caught the bad guy.For something that tries to be so hi-tech in its approach, each crime scene they wander into wearing their civilian clothing, perhaps strapping on a pair of rubber gloves if you are lucky, and then contaminate the whole crime scene. The crawl about the carpet in their designer denims, leaving their own fibres behind, trample mud and dirt and every other sample in on their shoes, actually for what these supposed desk bound scientists do it is amazing that there is any need for a police force at all. They not only gather the evidence but they go out and find the bad guy ! Once they do that they even interrogate and break them ! Not bad for a bunch of desk jockeys !

With all of the devices and computer programmes they have they at their disposal they can take your crappy pixilated security camera picture, and from a tiny grainy snippet they can render whole heads in 3D, and if that is not enough to get your juices going then wait until you see and hear what they can do with a simple tape recording from a telephone boothe. With a few touches of buttons, a whiz and a click here and there they can take car noises away, take out that deafening sea gull that just happens to be flying past and that train going by fifty miles away and then you are left with a crystal clear voice telling them I did it, I killed him, or that type of thing. Actually this would have me so scared witless in the good old US of A that I would be too scared to even jaywalk for the threat of having these guys on my tail.The sad thing about this is there is a really good cast behind this show. William L Peterson (Gil Grissom) has had his moments of brilliance in some of his movie outings but here he needs to be held partially responsible for what the finished product is like as he takes an executive producer credit too, but then again I guess it beats the day job. This would be an actors dream role for easy money, go in and spout some lines, you don’t have to have any character traits to worry about and you don’t need to show any emotion, and then collect your paycheck at the end of the week. Kerching !

So dear reader, the only people who are likely to be reading this are the fans of the series and what I say here will not deter you buying another season as you have all the others. For those, there are a few audio commentaries that you can drool over. If by chance that is not the case, and that you are not a fan but just an inquisitive reader, then I hope I have done my job well enough to avoid another convert being made.There are so many great TV shows out there, like ‘Deadwood’, ‘Oz’, ‘The Sopranos’ and ‘Carnivale’, so even if it is just a repeat showing please go and watch and be entertained by them instead.'C.S.I. Season 4.2' is now available via AmazonUK in the UK, no US date yet given, and is available online at other stores in a full season box set too. You can read more about the DVD in our database.

Jerry Bruckheimer - View Jerry Bruckheimer Pictures - Jerry Bruckheimer News

Click to launch this Jerry Bruckheimer gallery

Marg Helgenberger - View Marg Helgenberger Pictures - Marg Helgenberger News

Click to launch this Marg Helgenberger gallery

Your Talkback on this Story

Note posts made on our older Talkback system will still show below. However, new posts can only be made via the new system (above). We will export the old comments to the new shortly. You can still comment as a guest on the new system but it also allows you to login using various social network and other accounts.

Other features coming soon.

Talkback

page: 1

TOO FUNNYJul 15th, 2005 - 00:54:14

Geez Andy tell us how you really feel!

Report this comment

DanaJul 15th, 2005 - 02:34:10

Andy,
I couldn't agree more!!!!!!I HATE this stupid show and all its spinoffs.

Report this comment

JulesNov 28th, 2005 - 19:13:08

Andy - Deadwood? Carnivale? You have to be kidding!!!

Report this comment

ameliaJul 12th, 2006 - 16:07:04

well guess what if u guys don't like it then just shut up about it ok!! marg keeps doing the surgery so she could keep working ok? so shut up!!!!!! i like this show ok? so i know people have different opinion and alot of people actullay like this show so be quiet about it!!

Report this comment

LauraAug 11th, 2006 - 19:08:06

I agree entirely with what you are saying. The show is rather unrealistic to how quickly evidence is recovered and the method for which the CSI members use to find such evidence. However, I love watching the show. I find a way to get past most of this and enjoy watching what I believe to be good acting and it's fun for me to see how the actors interact with each other. It is true that the show stretches reality sometimes to a point that I can no longer bare it. At times like these, I change the channel to good old Food Network (unless Emril is on) and find something else to watch. I believe you should do the same and while ranting is fun, you shouldn't ruin somebody else's for enjoyment. Although I have never bought CSI merchandice, I truly adore this show and have been hooked for quite some time. I would appreciate it greatly if you would keep your malicious and slanderous opinions of the show to yourself. Thank you.

Report this comment

Any mous !Mar 20th, 2007 - 22:39:32

Oh my God.... despite the great and funny review it does not beat Laura's comment...... come on has anyone else read this ???? She reads a review and then asks for the reviewer to keep their opinion to themselves ! If they did this there would be no review - d'oh !!!!!

Keep up the good work folks !

Report this comment

page: 1

DVD

DVD Review: C.S.I Season 4.2

DVD Reviews

Jerry Bruckheimer - View Jerry Bruckheimer Pictures - Jerry Bruckheimer News

Marg Helgenberger - View Marg Helgenberger Pictures - Marg Helgenberger News

Your Talkback on this Story

Talkback

Similar articles

Latest Headlines in DVD

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation: Series 4.2

Related Articles

External Links

From Sites We Like

Latest PopEater News

Latest Cinema Blend News

Latest Tech Herald News

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print