DVD Reviews

By Jeff Swindoll May 30, 2007, 13:12 GMT

DVD Review: Hannibal Rising (Unrated)

There is a certain folly in always trying to explain the origins of evil (and popular movie villains). That being said, I’ll have to say that I did enjoy the story and thought that the production design was gorgeous. It’s the performance of the lead that really rubbed me the wrong way in comparing him to what has come before. I don’t know how it compares with the book but the film made the book seem not as horrible as I was led to believe.

What the back of the box says:
“In Red Dragon we learned who he was. In The Silence Of The Lambs, we learned how he did it. Now comes the most chilling chapter in the saga of Hannibal Lecter - the one that answers the most elusive question of all - why? Written by Thomas Harris, the best-selling author of the Hannibal book series, this "fascinating and terrifying journey into the making of a monster" (Pete Hammond, Maxim) reveals for the first time the metamorphosis of a brilliant medical student into "Hannibal The Cannibal." Good Morning America's Joel Siegel says, "if you can keep your eyes open, you're going to get scared."

I’ll have to admit that I’ve not read the book and I didn’t see this film in its theatrical cut. The book got horrible reviews (accusing Thomas Harris of doing a poor job to finally kill off the monster that haunts him) and the film did as well. Young Hannibal Lector witnesses the death of his sister at the hands of Lithuanian looters and when he grows up into Gaspard Ulliel. He then goes to France to find his aunt played by Gong Li and eventually decides to find the men who butchered and ate his sister and get his revenge.What makes this movie different from those that preceded it is that Thomas Harris wrote the screenplay as well as the novel that it was based on. The problem arises in the casting. Gaspard Ulliel is no Anthony Hopkins (but who would be?) and this is probably the shadow that kept a lot of actors away from the role. They knew that they’d be compared to the “Sir” and that they’d be the one whose liver is served with fava beans and a nice Chianti in the press. Sadly, young Ulliel looks more like the Joker than I would imagine a young Hannibal Lector to be. He also seems to be posing more than forming a character. This will be a large bone of contention with Lector fans and looking over the list of potential actors at IMDB, Ulliel is not the one that I’d have picked to fill the role (Rupret Friend gets my vote of those listed that had headshots). Not to mention that he’s so obviously French and Hopkins is so obviously British.

The movie is issued in both a 131 minute unrated widescreen (2.35:1 enhanced for 16x9 televisions) version as well as the 121 minute fullscreen theatrical edition. I’m unsure why it was done this way. It seems odd that if you wanted the theatrical cut that you’re stuck with the fullscreen version, punishment perhaps? Special features include a commentary with director Peter Webber and producer Martha De Laurentiis. Next is 4 minutes of deleted scenes with an optional commentary by Webber. There’s also the 16 minute “Hannibal Lecter: The Origin of Evil” which interviews producer Martha De Laurentiis, Maitland McDonagh (Sr. movie editor or TVGuide.com), Gaspard Ulliel, Peter Webber, Rhys Ifans (“Grutas”), stunt coordinator Lee Sheward, and production designer Allan Starski. It’s followed by the 7 minute “Allan Starski: Designing Horror and Elegance” which is a solo interview with him and some footage of producer Dino De Laurentiis around the set. Finally there’s a trailer gallery with the theatrical trailer and the teaser trailer. Though it was not as bad as I had thought, I still found Hannibal Rising lacking. I hate to rag further on Gaspard Ulliel but he was just not up to snuff as everyone’s favorite cannibal. If the role had been better cast then I think that the film would’ve had a better chance at the box office.

Hannibal Rising (Unrated) is now available at Amazon. It is available for pre-order at AmazonUK for a June 25th release. Visit the DVD database for more information.

And Also

Look Back at the Worst Celebrity Breakups

Look Back at the Worst Celebrity Breakups - PopEater
Office 2010 confirmed for June 2010 - The Tech Herald
Left 4 Dead 2 DLC News Coming Soon - Cinema Blend
'Brangelina' Author Sees Split in '15-18 Months' - PopEater
A&E series 'Hoarders' and 'Intervention' premiere Monday, Nov. 30th, preview

Anthony Hopkins - View Anthony Hopkins Pictures - Anthony Hopkins News

Click to launch this Anthony Hopkins gallery

Your Talkback on this Story

Latest Headlines in DVD

Older Talkback

page: 1

DoogerMay 30th, 2007 - 13:54:47

No only was the production gorgeous! So was Gong Li.

Report this comment

Jeff SwindollMay 30th, 2007 - 21:14:54

As for Gong Li, that goes without saying ;).

The more I think about the film it seems to come from a monetary place. I mean it's not like Harris came up with an good idea for the book, wrote it, and then it was tranformed into a movie. From what I hear, Dino De Laurentiis basically said we're continuing the series and we can do it with or without you. That's not a good place to be. There are some rather obvious (and perhaps silly) references to Silence, such as the Japanese mask that Hannibal puts on (he's wearing it on the cover) that alludes to the mask in Silence (the movie). Did Harris describe the mask as such in the book for Silence? It's been many moons since I read it. The production was well made, but it still didnt feel like it was made for anything but to cash in on Hannibal Lecter (and what would Hannibal think of that? I bet he'd eat Dino's brain).

Did anyone think of the after the credits scene in Young Sherlock Holmes when they watched the final scenes in Rising? Don't know why I thought of that.

It was an okay movie, but I still expected more.

Cheers.

Report this comment

Patrick L.May 30th, 2007 - 21:23:58

Personally, I thought the movie was horrible and trashed any cred that Harris had established with Silence and Hannibal. Could it have been better with a better actor in the Lector role? Yes. Can anyone do the role better than Hopkins? Hell No! However, both the book and the movie were written by Harris so the fault is on him. When did Hannibal become the hero? Not to mention some sort of Samurai warrior. That was just stupid. The film had the style to match Hannibal, but none of the grit. Even Red Dragon was better than this.

Report this comment

....Oct 3rd, 2007 - 16:29:34

I am just wonder if Hannibal really ate his sister. It was in the M scene before he cut the M on that guys chest...the guy said 'you ate her too...' I was a little confused...please help!!
Shelbi

Report this comment

saraNov 1st, 2007 - 03:02:59

When he said 'you ate her to'.. he was talking about afterwards when they were all starving and after they already cooked her. Lector didn't know, but he was hungry and they gave him food and it turned out to be his sister. So he pretty much didn't figure out till afterwards..

Report this comment

Jordyn.Jun 15th, 2009 - 03:37:49

I loved this movie as well as Ulliel. He brought me fear, pity, sadness, hatred and love for the young Hannibal Lector. ((not to mention hes a real hottie))
I think the 'Joker' in him was amazing and I cant wait to read the book to understand what the reviewer is referring to when he\she disagrees in this outlook on the young Hannibal. until that time, i give this movie three thumbs up.

Report this comment

page: 1

DVD

DVD Reviews

DVD Review: Hannibal Rising (Unrated)

And Also

Anthony Hopkins - View Anthony Hopkins Pictures - Anthony Hopkins News

Your Talkback on this Story

Latest Headlines in DVD

Older Talkback

Hannibal Rising (Unrated)

Related Articles

External Links

From Sites we Like

In Monsters and Critics

Corporate

The Fine Print