DVD Reviews
DVD Review: Night Watch
By Jeff Swindoll Jun 16, 2006, 16:40 GMT
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
On the Web
Latest Headlines in DVD
- 1. Take Shelter - Blu-ray Review
- 2. The Rum Diary – Blu-ray Review
- 3. Doctor Who: The Sensorites – DVD Review
- 4. Doctor Who: The Caves of Androzani – DVD Review
- 5. The Phantom of the Opera at the Royal Albert Hall - Blu-ray Review
Older Talkback
page: 1
Hi Jeff,
just finished your review for Night Watch and it read more like Dull Watch !
For a movie you enjoyed why such a bland review and the review itself sounds for the most part a regurgitation of the box back panel until you get to the last few paras which sound again like the box tech specs mixed in with an occasional 'I liked it' type of thing.
Just for starters, where is the reference to that this is based on a top selling Russian comic book series ? And the release date for the UK (stated in the info box at the top of the page) is incorrect as it was released in the UK back in April and not June as indicated. The tip of the iceberg, but hey I am not going to give a review of a review because that's not my job....
But just a q for those out there.... is it not about time that reviewers actually did some homework on what they watch and type away to give an informed read to the punters who view these very pages ?
In short, a great movie but a poor and lazy review.... the site should hang it's head in shame :(
SP
The UK release date was changed on the listing to give the movie more exposure on the main DVD page since it didn't have coverage when it came out on April 24th in the UK. We have also posted several news articles about the movie since the date for the U.S. release was announced and are participating with Fox in a web-based scavenger hunt to help promote the movie.
As to Jeff's review of the film, I haven't seen the movie so I can't compare it to the review. I will leave that to him to defend. He gave the movie three and half stars and seemed to have liked it, but there can always be more detail put into a movie review. Of course, some people prefer a short 'get to the point' review so I guess it is a matter of taste. Sorry for the confusion on the UK release date. The information has now been changed. As always, thanks for reading M&C!
Question posed by SP:
But just a q for those out there.... is it not about time that reviewers actually did some homework on what they watch and type away to give an informed read to the punters who view these very pages ?
Response: Night Watch is from a series of NOVELS by Russian author Sergei Lukyanenko, not a comic book. Nightwatch is a superhero character in Marvel comics and has NOTHING to do with this movie. That's the only Nightwatch COMIC that I could find. I digress.
More importantly, knowledge of either of those Night Watches really has nothing to do with the enjoyment of the movie. I know nothing about Lukyanenko's novels and am only reviewing this DVD (again you don't have to know anything of the books to enjoy the movie). Fox did not send me a copy of the book, comic or otherwise.
Did you want spoilers in the description maybe? The idea is to give the reader a general idea of what the movie is about. My description has much more information than the back of the box.
I believe that you've already been informed about why the date was changed on the main DVD page. That was a technical issue and had to do with the promotional aspects of the site.
You don't have to know the history of ANY movie to actually enjoy the movie you're watching. If that were the case, there would be no reviews. We'd all be down at the library researching. ;}
Cheers and keep reading.
page: 1

Your Talkback on this Story